Wines To Pair with Thanksgiving Leftovers #SundaySupper

I was excited when I saw this week’s #SundaySupper theme – “What to do with Thanksgiving Leftovers“.  The theme provides a perfect opportunity to broach the perennial, and all to often fraught with anxiety, topic of which wines to pair with the Thanksgiving meal.  For you see, many of today’s Thanksgiving leftovers are a prime example of the challenge Thanksgiving presents.  It’s not the Turkey, which is the centerpiece of the meal, it’s the diversity of food and the corresponding tastes (sweet, sour, salty, bitter, and unami ) presented by the sides, sauces, desserts, etc.  Not to mention the diversity of preferences among those gathered around your table.

My recommendations for seizing this wonderful opportunity 😉 are twofold.  First, select food friendly wines, and secondly depending on how many folks are gathered around your table, have a wide assortment of wines from sparkling wines to whites, rosés,  and reds.

Wines To Pair With Thanksgiving Leftovers #SundaySupper
Thanksgiving Leftovers – Image courtesy of

The other reason I’ve been looking forward to this week is more personal. My signature dish for Thanksgiving is a Spiced Pumpkin Cheesecake with Brown Sugar and Bourbon Cream. It’s seriously good cheesecake that my family loves.  But every year I have leftover pumpkin puree I swear I’m going to use after Thanksgiving, but inevitably end up finding in the back of the fridge sometime in January!  Not only that, one can only eat so many Turkey sandwiches! So I’m looking forward to the inspiring and creative recipes the #SundaySupper put on the Family table this week!

Check out this week’s lineup and my corresponding recommended wine pairings.

Breakfast & Brunch

Sparkling wines are underrated as food pairing partners, but for my money they offer the most breadth in terms of pairing.  They can work not only as an aperitif, but throughout the meal through to dessert. Pair these items with Lucien Albrecht Cremant d’Alsace Brut Rosé.  It’s a sparkling rosé from Alsace, France with a soft, fruity strawberry, raspberry and a hint of citrus peel character that will be a good match for the sweet character of these delicious breads.  Go ahead, slather butter on them, the bubbles will cleanse your palate and get you ready for the next bite!

Main Course

Pair these dishes with a Chardonnay.  I like the 2010 Michael Pozzan “Annabella-Special Selection” Napa Valley Chardonnay because of its judicious use of oak, bold, yet balanced acid profile and tropical fruit, citrus, vanilla, and clove character.  It doesn’t hurt that it was #75 on the Wine Enthusiast Top 100 Values for 2012 either! 

Pair these well spiced aromatic dishes with Riesling.  I love the 2011 Chateau Ste. Michelle & Dr. Loosen Eroica Riesling. It’s off-dry  with vibrant acidity and a beautiful white peach, grapefruit and mineral character.
Pair these dishes with a white Rhone blend. What’s great about blends is that the combination of grape varietals creates vinous synergy – a wine that is greater than the sum of its parts. Look for the 2011 Tablas Creek Patelin de Tablas Blanc. It’s a blend of Grenache Blanc, Viognier, Marsanne, and Roussanne. It’s a crisp and aromatic wine with honeysuckle and stone fruit aromas that follow onto the palate. It also has very good acidity and an appealing minerality that make it versatile food partner.
Dry rosés are not just for summer, they can also work well for Thanksgiving too.  But avoid the sweet “White Zinfandel-ish pink wines!  The sweetness will clash with your cranberry relish and these wines lack the palate refreshing acidity to be versatile food partners.  One of my favorites is the 2011 Bonny Doon Vin Gris de Cigar, a tasty blend of Grenache, Roussanne, Grenache Blanc, and Mourvèdre that is chock full of strawberry, stone fruit, watermelon, and citrus flavors.

Pair these dishes with Pinot Noir – a classic Thanksgiving recommendation because it’s fruity, low tannin high acidity nature.  On top of that, many Pinot have a cranberry, herbal, and baking spice character that complement, not only the turkey, but the timings too.  Look for the 2011 Hahn Winery California Pinot Noir. It has wonderful mixed berry, lavender, and spice aromatics, that follow onto the palate.

Pair these dishes with 2010 Ridge Vineyards “Three Valleys” Sonoma Zinfandel Blend. It’s a blend of Zinfandel, Petite Sirah, Syrah, Grenache, Alicante Bouchet, and a significant dose of old-vine Carignane that adds depth and acidity to this tasty blend.  It’s well-balanced has a bright red berry fruit, herbal and spice character. 

Soups, Salads, Sides & Starters

Pair these with a Brut sparkling wine, which is the most food friendly style of sparkling wine. One of my favorites is Mumm Brut Prestige. It shows biscuit, sweet citrus, red fruit and subtle floral aromas.  and cherry , vanilla and citrus flavors with a creamy mouthfeel. 

Pair these dishes with a Sauvignon Blanc.  I recommend the 2010 Leese-Fitch Sauvignon Blanc. It’s dry, crisp and clean, with citrus, flower and mineral flavors. 

Pair this dish with 2010 Ridge Vineyards “Three Valleys” Sonoma Zinfandel Blend

Sweets & Desserts

Pair this dessert with a Sauternes, a sweet white wine from France.  Look for the 2009 Chateau Doisy-Vedrines Sauternes.  It’s a rich and layered, with good acidity and a complex honeyed citrus, floral, white peach, fig and persimmon character.  And if you happen to have any leftover apple pie or fruit based desserts…Yum!

Pair these desserts with an Oloroso Sherry, a rich dense style of sherry.  I recommend the Sandeman Jerez-Xérès-Sherry Rich Old Oloroso Royal Corregidor. This one is redolent of caramel, butterscotch and fig, with notes of pear, orange and raisins, and a long sensual finish. And should you happen to have any leftover pumpkin, sweet potato, or pecan pie…O…M…G!

*Clink* – Here’s to you and your loved ones.  Remember that Thanksgiving is, most of all, a time to be thankful – for family, friends, and life’s many pleasures, including great food and wines. Happy holidays!

Please join on us on Twitter throughout the day during #SundaySupper on November 18.  In the evening we will meet at 7pm EST for our weekly #SundaySupper live chat.

All you have to do is follow the #SundaySupper hashtag or you can follow us through TweetChat.

We’d also love to feature your recipe for Thanksgiving Leftovers on our #SundaySupper Pinterest board to share them with all of our followers, too.


Related posts you might enjoy:

66 Comments Add yours

  1. Great post as usual Martin! That cheesecake sounds incredible, a reason enough to make pumpkin puree!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much Paula!

  2. I want that cheesecake recipe Martin! I have been looking forward to your pairings this week. Time to make a trip to Total Wine. Hope you have an amazing Thanksgiving!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much Megan! The recipe is from Cook’s Illustrated…i’ll pin it to my Pinterest Recipes; Desserts board

  3. diabeticfoodie says:

    Great suggestions, as always!

  4. juanitascocina says:

    Oh my gosh, did you just give me permission to drink wine with my breakfast cinnamon rolls?

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Jen…Indeed…though I didn’t think you needed permission;-) It’s always 5 o’clock somewhere!

  5. Oh, that cheesecake sounds divine! And thanks so much for these wonderful pairings…it makes me look like I know what I’m doing at my table 😉

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks Heather…the classics always work for Thanksgiving – Sparkling wine, Pinot Noir, and Riesling!

  6. I wouldn’t have had any idea what wine to pair with my Turkey Reuben. Thanks Martin!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      My pleasure Cindy! Not only will the Rose be a good match, so would the sparkling rose, and the Mumm Brut Prestige. There’s rarely just “one” answer, and then of course there’s your personal preference!

  7. I love your knowledge about these things!! Every week I look forward to seeing the pairs!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much Amanda!

  8. I always learn so much from your pairings. And I love a good Zin, so hapy to see you paired my dish with one.

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks Brianne…that Ridge is a good one too!

  9. Hezzi-D says:

    Great suggestions for wine pairings!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks Heather! Wishing you and your a great Thanksgiving!

  10. Dara says:

    What a fantastic post! I love these wine ideas. Thank you for sharing your expertise!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much Bobbi! What wine(s) do you enjoy at Thanksgiving?

  11. Patti says:

    Great suggestions Martin! You have your work cut out with us don’t you?!!:o)

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      LOL…yes I do. More oft that not, the name of the recipe isn’t enough info, and even when it is, the #SS bunch is so creative, there’s usually a twist that make the pairing more challenging. Not to mention the sheer number of dishes at times! Having said that I always look forward to the weeks I do the wine pairings!

  12. As always, I am amazed at all of the hard work you do for the #SundaySupper posts. I know nothing about wine at all so it’s always fun to see what you pair my dishes with. : )

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much for your kind words! It’s a challenge at times, but I certainly enjoy working with such a creative bunch of foodies!

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much for the kind words Amy!

  13. sheilaly says:

    I love all your wine recommendations! I have learned so much. Thanks for sharing.

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks so much. Happy to give you my $.02 anytime!

  14. Laura Hunter says:

    I am going shopping tomorrow for our Thanksgiving feast, which won’t happen until Sunday since Thursday isn’t a holiday for us. I am so glad you posted these tips on wine parings so I can do a better job this year with the wine selection.

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      Thanks Laura…The classics – Pinot, Bubbly (Brut), and Riesling are always a safe bet…

  15. Great suggestions as always. I’m looking forward to trying the 2011 Bonny Doon Vin Gris de Cigar sounds like summer in a glass with all those different fruit flavors.

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      I drink more than my share of Rosé and that’s a good one! Got a couple of bottles in my fridge now!

  16. I love grenache. So happy to hear I can pair my sandwich with grenache. Thanks Martin as always.

    1. Martin D. Redmond says:

      My pleasure Sarah!

  17. I love Zin, so no problem pairing it with the enchiladas! But now on to more pressing matters… where the heck is the recipe for this Spiced Pumpkin Cheesecake with Brown Sugar and Bourbon Cream about which you speak?? What a tease! Have a great holiday.

    1. Support says:

      Hmmm…I posted it to my Pinterest account. Thought I shared that with you. I’ll email it to you. Happy Thanksgiving!

  18. Faye Leong says:

    Lucien Albrecht Cremant d’Alsace Brut Rosé….I have to hunt for it over here….thanks for your recommendation, Martin!

Leave a Reply